Showing posts with label short fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label short fiction. Show all posts

Sunday, May 3, 2026

My Atwood Project, Part 13: Moral Disorder

This is the third of three short books that Atwood published in the six years between Oryx and Crake (2003) and the second book of the MaddAddam series, The Year of the Flood (2009). I was looking forward to rereading Moral Disorder (2006) because my favorite Atwood story, “My Last Duchess,” is in it. What an eye-opener to find that every single story (or chapter?) is autobiographical to a certain extent. 


As Atwood says in the memoir: "It’s a mix of Nell and Tig stories—these two characters would appear later in Old Babes in the Wood, and they bear more than a coincidental relationship to Graeme and me—and stories of childhood…. The last two stories, however, are valedictions. A valediction is an act of bidding farewell. The first valediction, ‘The Labrador Fiasco,’ is for my father, who had died ten years before. The second—’The Boys at the Lab’—is for my mother..."

In fact, this seems like a practice memoir, or a first draft of one. The full title is Moral Disorder and Other Stories, and each section has a title on its first page, but in the the table of contents they are simply labeled with chapter numbers, as if it were a single narrative rather than a collection. The title comes from a novel that Graeme started but never finished.

Chapter 1, “The Bad News,” is a Nell and Tig story, which begins in the present and then transposes them to Roman times to show how the more things change, the more they stay the same.


The next four stories are about Atwood’s childhood and youth, all with analogs in the memoir. 

  • In Chapter 2, “The Art of Cooking and Serving,” first-person narration, Atwood as a child prepares for the birth of her sister Ruth. It’s an anxiety-inducing time, as their mother is older than is usual -- forty-two, we learn in the memoir.  
  • Chapter 3, “The Headless Horseman,” also first person, is about a Halloween costume passed from Atwood to younger sister Ruth.
  • Chapter 4, “My Last Duchess,” also first person, is about Atwood’s final year in high school and early boyfriend. I love it because I can relate both to young Margaret, a strong student with a boyfriend, and also to the English teacher, as I became one later. I also love the title poem, which I have taught, and Tess of the d’Urbervilles, which they also study. 
  • Chapter 5, “The Other Place,” first person, recounts in a vague and general way Atwood’s restless first years out of college. 

In Chapter 6, “Monopoly,” we return to the Nell and Tig stories. This is about when Atwood was officially introduced to Tig and Oona’s (Graeme and Shirley's) children as Graeme’s new -- girlfriend? The narrator decides during the story that Oona/Shirley considers her a governess, a glorified babysitter. All this harks back to Life Before Man, the fictionalized story of Graeme’s disaster of an open marriage with Shirley, before committing to Atwood.

 

In Chapter 7, “Moral Disorder,” we continue with Nell and Tig, and all the animals on the farm: how they are acquired, and often, how they die. Considering all this come and go in the animal world leads Nell/Atwood to the realization that Tig/Gibson does not want to marry, or for Nell to have children


Chapter 8, “White Horse,” is also in the Nell and Tig framework, but it’s mostly about Atwood's sister Ruth, called Lizzie in the story, and her mental health struggles. When Atwood let Ruth know that she’d have a chapter in her memoir, Ruth replied, “I don’t actually need one, it's all in Moral Disorder.” 


In Chapter 9, “The Entities,” Oona/Shirley insists that Nell/Atwood buy her a house. Then she dies in it. Again, it’s all real, and in the memoir.


Chapter 10, “The Labrador Fiasco,” returns to the first person, and tells of Atwood’s father’s decline. It contains a story within a story: Atwood’s mother is reading to him an account of a real expedition to Labrador in the Canadian wilderness. The expedition is a fiasco, due to inadequate knowledge and poor preparation. Atwood’s father gleefully imagines how he would have done better. I view this as a reflection on his life as a man who was a successful wilderness trekker.

 

Finally, Chapter 11, “The Boys at the Lab,” continues in the first person and tells of Atwood’s mother’s decline. I found the connection to these “boys,” the students who assisted Atwood’s father, intriguing. I get the impression, from the many cold and abandoning mothers in Atwood’s work, that her mother was not as warm with her children as she was with other adults, that perhaps she regretted leaving behind an independent and unconventional life to become a mother. 


Sunday, April 26, 2026

My Atwood Project, Part 12: The Penelopiad and The Tent

I have a degree in comparative literature, so you might think that I love retellings, as they permit the reader to compare the same story from different points of view, or in different time periods. But I honestly haven't found that many that I like. I couldn't even finish The Wide Sargasso Sea, about the mad woman in the attic from Jane Eyre. But perhaps my soft spot for Jane is too soft. I also love Pride and Prejudice too much to be interested in P & P & Zombies. Go ahead and call me a reactionary in the comments.

I did enjoy the retelling of The Iliad in The Song of Achilles (2011) by Madeline Miller, which recounts the siege of Troy from the point of view of Patroclus, Achilles' closest friend and possible lover. Here in The Penelopiad (2005) we have another retelling of The Iliad, this time from the point of view of Penelope, left behind in Ithaca as her wily husband Odysseus goes to wage war in Troy for ten years, then spends ten more years coming home. Penelope as a young bride reminded me of Iris in the Blind Assassin: listening to her lover’s stories, and being bossed around by the actual woman of the house, with little to do but give birth, preferably to a son.

Atwood also calls attention to the maids that Odysseus and his son unjustly killed upon his return, when he also killed the suitors who were vying to claim Penelope. Why did he hang them? What had they done, besides sleep with or be raped by the suitors, which they had very little choice about? Atwood calls it at one point an “honor killing.” This focus on the treatment of servants, especially female ones, recalls Alias Grace, which also examines how servants are treated as disposable sex objects for the upper classes. 


Toward the end of the short novel, which consists mostly of Penelope’s first-person narration, interspersed with song and dance from the maids, is a chapter titled "An Anthropology Lecture," where the maids offer a metaphorical reading of the incident. The symbolism of twelve maidens, led by a thirteenth in the form of Penelope, could be argued to represent a formerly matriarchal culture, represented by the thirteen lunar cycles, being taken over by the patriarchy. Atwood is also careful to point out that Odysseus taking his young bride to his home was counter to the prevailing tradition of the husband moving in with the bride's family and contributing the bridal gifts to her household. 


Penelope alternates between telling the story of what happened in her lifetime, and relating encounters with other souls in the underworld. Most of them avoid her except the fatuous Helen. In the short fiction collection The Tent (2006), "It's Not Easy Being Half Divine" presents a short retelling of Helen's side of the story in a modern setting. "Salome Was a Dancer" does the same, portraying Salome in seven layers of cheesecloth rather than seven veils. In "The Nightingale," Philomena and her sister Procne speak of the horrifying husband who mistreated them both. The treatment of women in myth was definitely a topic preoccupying Atwood at the time.


The Tent begins with "Life Stories," a sort of anti-memoir about letting go of the past, “taking it apart,” to become only a whisper. This made me smile, as the whole reason I'm doing this project of rereading Atwood is because of her lengthy, detailed memoir. She claims in The Book of Lives that her publishers talked her into it. 


The title story is a metaphor for writing. The writer is compared to a refugee in a tent, who is compelled to write the story of the vast, cold world around her on the inside of her tent, even though she may attract the attention of those who wish to harm her. 


The pieces are short and experimental, often in the second person, often about writing, like the title story, and "Plots for Exotics," in which a character wants to audition for a protagonist role but is told she may not because she's an "exotic."


The collection has much more in common with Good Bones and Murder in the Dark than with her more traditional short stories, which make their return the same year, 2006, in Moral Disorder.


Thursday, March 26, 2026

My Atwood Project, Part 7B: Murder in the Dark + Good Bones

I was going to include Good Bones, Murder in the Dark, and the combination volume, Good Bones and Simple Murders, with Wilderness Tips, but they deserve their own post, as they contain a very different type of short fiction. Murder in the Dark came out in Canada in 1983, then some pieces from it were combined with most of Good Bones (1992) and reissued as Good Bones and Simple Murders in 1994. 



Murder in the Dark contains several short pieces -- not traditional short stories -- that seem to be autobiographical and focus on the present or recent past, as is typical for Atwood’s work from that pre-Handmaid’s Tale era. It also includes some feminist pieces, such as “Simmering,” in which men take over all cooking, and some writing experiments, such as “Happy Endings,” which briefly explores several ways a relationship might play out.


Good Bones, on the other hand, focuses more on retelling and perspective changes, such as retelling the story of the Little Red Hen to highlight her passivity, or Queen Gertrude's reaction to her son's harangue in Hamlet, which portrays her as the opposite of passive. Atwood went on to pursue this method in longer works, The Penelopiad and Hag-Seed, the first a retelling of the Odyssey from Penelope's point of view and the second a retelling of The Tempest from Caliban's. Another type of perspective change is strange making, where something known is described in a new way to make it unrecognizable at first. For example, in the story titled “The Adventure,” we might first assume some people are on a trip, but it turns out to be a description of sperm implanting an egg. 


The pieces I like most focus on humanity's problematic future, because as you might know, I'm a big sci-fi fan. In “Epaulettes,” war is replaced by a sort of beauty pageant for men. They don fancy uniforms and speak about their wishes for “the good of humanity,” just like female pageant participants. The winner rules the world, but only for a year.


In other short pieces, such as “Hardball” and “We Want It All,” Atwood takes on pollution and climate change. She was well informed before many of us because her father was a scientist who studied insect infestations in the forests of northern Canada, and shared his opinions on the disappearing wilderness with his family at the dinner table. 


Murder in the Dark and Good Bones each contain 27 stories -- coincidence? Eleven pieces, less than half, from Murder in the Dark made the move into the combined book, whereas almost every piece from Good Bones, all but four, made the cut. I’m curious why neither “Epaulettes” nor “The Adventure” was included. Both “Simmering” (included) and “Epaulettes” (not) place men in traditionally female roles; perhaps they were considered too similar. 


At any rate, for the full Atwood experience, you would have to read both the earlier collections, because neither is fully represented in the combined volume.